Crisp trade not a done deal, Boston forcing Tribe’s hand
Monday, January 23rd, 2006The Coco Crisp trade rumors have reached a boiling point, apparently set to flame by the Boston Red Sox. In a report on Cleveland.com, a Boston reporter suggested the Red Sox leaked the conversations to the media in order to force the Indians hand.
The proposed deal sends Crisp to the Red Sox for pitcher Guillermo Mota and third baseman Andy Marte. Another variation includes David Riske and Josh Bard for pitching prospect Manny Delcarmen.
The Indians are in an awkward position. This trade, in the short-term, provides little to improve the team in 2006. By trading Crisp, a hole in left field needs filled. Current rumors have the Indians trading Mota or another bullpen arm such as Arthur Rhodes or David Riske to the Phillies for center fielder Jason Michaels. Without knowing much about Michaels, its hard to suggest he’s on the verge of stardom like Crisp.
Marte, however, is the right-handed power hitter Shapiro has been unable to land in the free agent market. With Boone a question mark at third (Boone and the Indians hold a mutual option for 2007), Marte fits in nicely with long-term plans.
The trade talks leave the Indians in a public relations neverland - not quite completely committed to making a run at the World Series in 2006 but also unwilling to sacrifice the future for a fleeting swing at the title. Also at play, though, is the Red Sox’s very obvious desire to land Crisp. Perhaps Indians’ GM Mark Shapiro feels he can the Beantowners to overpay.
Shapiro stands close to the precipice on this deal. Indians fans could easily see the move as another example of owner Larry Dolan unwilling to pony up the cash to keep a talented fan favorite. And with the White Sox outclassing the Indians in the offseason market, perhaps Tribe management sees a better opportunity in 2007.
Popularity: 19% [?]